Home › Guides › Facebook ads vs Instagram ads
Facebook ads vs Instagram ads: which should you run?
Facebook ads and Instagram ads are placements in the same Meta campaign, not two separate platforms you have to choose between. For Leads and Sales campaigns, Meta is removing the option to pick placements in the ad set. So run both, make creative for each, and compare them in your own breakdowns on qualified leads.
The Facebook ads vs Instagram ads question usually comes from a business owner with a fixed budget who wants to spend it where their customers are. It is a fair instinct, but most comparisons answer it with global user counts and cost benchmarks from other people's accounts.
This guide answers it from Meta's own documentation instead: how the two apps sit inside one campaign, what has changed in placement settings, how to read the comparison in your own Ads Manager, and when it is still worth favouring one over the other.
Facebook and Instagram ads are one campaign
You do not buy Facebook ads and Instagram ads separately: Meta's page on choosing ad placements says one campaign can appear on Facebook, Messenger, Instagram, WhatsApp, Threads and Audience Network, depending on the objective. You build one campaign in Ads Manager, and each app is a set of placements inside it: Instagram alone has six, from Feed and Explore to Stories, Reels and search results.
Meta groups placements by how people experience the ad, not by app: its example is that Stories ads on Facebook, Messenger and Instagram give people a similar experience. That is why the useful comparison is often placement by placement, such as Stories against Feed, not app against app.
You also do not need an Instagram account to appear there. The same Meta page says your Facebook Page can serve as the voice of your ad on Instagram.
You may not be able to pick one any more
Meta is gradually removing ad set placement selection for Leads, App promotion and Sales campaigns, according to its page on Advantage+ placements. These objectives now default to Advantage+ placements. Awareness, Traffic and Engagement campaigns still let you choose placements by hand.
In practice, an "Instagram only" lead campaign is no longer a setting you can count on. If your account has not received the change yet, you can still edit Platforms and Placement controls in a Leads or Sales ad set. Meta notes that excluding any placement turns Advantage+ placements off.
The account-wide placement controls do not fill the gap. Meta's page on account controls lists the placements you can exclude for the whole ad account: Audience Network (two options), Facebook Marketplace and Facebook right column. Instagram is not on that list, and neither is Facebook Feed (checked 14 November 2026).
One exception matters for property advertisers. The same page says account controls do not apply to ads about housing, employment, financial products and services, or social issues, elections or politics. If your ads run under the housing category, read my guide to the housing special ad category first.
Facebook ads vs Instagram ads at a glance
The real differences between Facebook and Instagram ads are the placements, the creative each one suits and how you report on them, because the account, budget and targeting are shared.
| Where ads appear | Feed, Marketplace, right column, notifications, Business Explore, Stories, Reels, in-stream reels, search results | Feed, profile feed, Explore home, Stories, Reels, search results |
|---|---|---|
| Who you are on the ad | Your Facebook Page | Your Instagram account, or your Facebook Page |
| Campaign, budget, audience | Shared: one campaign in Ads Manager | |
| Pick one app only | Awareness, Traffic, Engagement: yes, with manual placements. Leads, Sales, App promotion: being removed | |
| Exclude at account level | Marketplace and right column | Not available |
| How to compare | Breakdown by Platform or Placement in Ads Manager | |
Why the cheaper platform in your report may not be the better one
A higher cost per result on Instagram does not mean Instagram is wasting money, and Meta's page about the delivery system and placements explains why. The system looks for the lowest average cost across the whole ad set, "not the lowest average cost for each placement". It buys the cheapest results it can find anywhere, even if that leaves one placement with a higher average.
Meta's worked example uses US dollars and a tiny budget, but the logic holds. With all placements on, Facebook averages $3 per result, Instagram $5 and Audience Network $1, and the ad set gets 9 results at $3 each. Turn Instagram off because it looks expensive, and the money moves to dearer Audience Network slots (now $3.40 on average): the ad set gets 8 results at $3.25 each. Instagram looked like the worst placement, yet the ad set did better with it on.
Meta's own summary is that one placement's higher average cost "doesn't necessarily mean it's inefficient". Meta also reports that, in its own experiment, ad sets using Advantage+ placements had an 11.7% lower cost per action on average than ad sets with manual placements. That is Meta's test, not a promise for your account, and it is the case Meta makes for Advantage+ placements.
How to compare Facebook and Instagram in your own account
Your own breakdown answers the question better than any global survey: Meta's page on breakdowns in Ads Manager shows how to split any campaign by Platform or Placement.
- Pick a campaign with enough history. A few weeks of steady spend is better than a few days.
- Open the breakdown. Select the campaign, ad set or ad, click Breakdown, then By delivery, and choose Platform. Switch to Placement to see Feed, Stories and Reels separately.
- Read spend, results and cost per result together. A placement that takes little budget at a higher cost may still be adding results you would not get elsewhere.
- Check lead quality outside Meta. Match leads to the placement they came from in your CRM or WhatsApp follow-up. For example, ten form fills from one placement are worth less than three booked consultations from another.
Two cautions. Meta says it may use statistical modelling in breakdowns when conversion data is missing or partial, so small differences between rows are not proof. And a placement's numbers include the creative that ran there: if your Reels results are poor because you ran a square image with text cut off, that is a creative problem, not an Instagram problem.
What you can still control
With ad set placement selection going for Leads and Sales campaigns, your control moves to the creative, the bid value and the objective. Meta's value rules are the main new lever.
- Creative per placement. Meta's asset customisation lets you replace or crop media for each group of placements, such as Feeds, or Stories and Reels, and edit the text for each. Give Instagram Stories and Reels a vertical video made for them.
- Value rules. Raise bids by up to 1,000% or lower them by up to 90% for select placements, ages, locations and other criteria. Meta warns your overall cost per result may increase, and value rules do not work with manual bid strategies such as bid cap or ROAS goal.
- The objective. Awareness, Traffic and Engagement campaigns still allow manual placements, so an Instagram-only Reels campaign for reach is still possible. In Traffic and Engagement, untick Allow limited spend to excluded placements if you mean it, or Meta may spend up to 5% of the budget on each placement you excluded. Do not rebuild a lead campaign under Traffic just to get the old control back: it would optimise for clicks or visits, not enquiries.
- Account controls. Use them for hard limits that apply to every campaign, such as keeping ads off Audience Network. Meta says changes to existing campaigns can take up to 48 hours.
My guide to Advantage+ placements covers these settings in more detail.
What I see in UAE accounts: a request to run "Instagram only" because that is where the owner sees ads on their own phone. Before changing anything, I open the Platform breakdown with them and look at qualified leads by platform, not cost per result. The better fix is usually vertical creative for Stories and Reels and faster WhatsApp follow-up, not cutting an app.
Which should you run? A rule for UAE lead-gen accounts
For a UAE business that wants leads or sales, the answer is usually both, in one campaign, judged on qualified leads. My rule of thumb:
Run both and let Meta allocate when:
- Your campaign uses the Leads or Sales objective, which is where Meta is taking ad set placement choice away.
- You have vertical video for Stories and Reels as well as feed creative.
- You can track which leads become sales, so Meta optimises towards real customers. My guide to Meta conversion leads explains how.
Lean towards one app when:
- Your goal is reach or engagement, where manual placements are still available, and you only have creative for one format.
- A brand rule means you cannot appear in certain placements at all; use account controls for that.
- Your own breakdown shows, over several weeks, that one platform brings leads your sales team cannot close. Fix creative and follow-up first; then use value rules to bid down rather than cutting it.
If WhatsApp is your follow-up channel, click-to-WhatsApp ads run on both Facebook and Instagram. My guide to click-to-WhatsApp ads vs instant forms compares the two lead routes.
What to do this week
- Run the breakdown check above on your main lead campaign for the last 30 days, by Platform and then by Placement.
- Count qualified leads per platform in your CRM or WhatsApp, not form fills.
- Check your creative in each placement's preview, especially Stories and Reels, and add a vertical version if one is missing.
- Check Advertising settings for account controls someone set earlier and forgot.
- Only then consider value rules, and give any change a few weeks before you judge it.
Still boosting posts from your phone? Read boost post vs Ads Manager first. If you would rather hand the set-up over, that is what my Facebook and Instagram ads management covers.
Frequently asked questions
Are Facebook ads and Instagram ads the same?+
Which is better, Facebook ads or Instagram ads?+
Can I run Instagram-only ads?+
Do I need an Instagram account to run ads on Instagram?+
Related
Not sure where your Meta budget is going?
Message me on WhatsApp or request a free campaign audit. I'll open your Platform and Placement breakdowns with you, check your tracking and creative for each placement, and show you where the leads really come from.